Avigdor Lieberman built his brand as the man who stands with the soldiers, the reservists and the career officers. In the first vote of the new Knesset, he sat in the same row as the parties he himself called terror supporters.
This is not a dispute over wording or tactics. It is an explicit promise that was broken, and its price is already visible in the Knesset presidium.
“Neither directly nor indirectly”
Two days after the election, Lieberman left no room for interpretation. “With me, my word is my word,” he wrote, “and everything I said before the election holds after it too. We will not sit with Bibi or with Tibi, not with Goldknopf and not with Deri. Not with Yasser Hujeirat and not with the rest of the terror supporters. Neither directly nor indirectly.”
On November 10 he drew the line again: Yisrael Beytenu will not agree to a minority government that relies on Ra’am and the Joint List, and will keep working with all its strength for those who serve: conscripts, reservists and career soldiers.
A week later came the first vote that put those words to the test.
Seven out of seven
On November 17, Matan Kahana was elected Speaker of the Knesset by 66 votes to 52. He would not have reached that majority without Ra’am and the Joint List, whose votes decided the election.
In that same vote, on that same side, sat all seven Yisrael Beytenu members. Lieberman himself included.
If the word “indirectly” means anything, this is it. Not a government yet, but a Knesset Speaker elected thanks to the very votes Lieberman promised not to rely on.
And the price came fast. The following night, Ahmad Tibi, Arafat’s former adviser, and Walid Taha, who refuses to call Hamas a terrorist organization, were confirmed as Deputy Speakers. Tibi, whom Lieberman promised not to sit with, now runs plenary sessions.
Then came the Hamas test
A day after the vote, a simple bill came up: a Knesset member who will not recognize Hamas as a terrorist organization will not enjoy the privileges of the office. Tibi led the Arab MKs out of the chamber, and the “Change Bloc” walked out after them and did not vote. The bill passed 48 to zero, without the votes of the bloc that elected Kahana.
Three years after October 7, after some 1,200 murdered and 251 hostages, recognizing Hamas as a terrorist organization should be the most obvious thing in Israel’s Knesset. Whoever leaves the chamber so as not to crack a partnership with those who refuse to say it has chosen a side.
That is what our graphic says in numbers: 100% for the Muslim Brotherhood, 0% for the soldiers.
Terror supporters are already running the Knesset
On November 18, Ahmad Tibi sat in the Speaker’s chair and ran the plenary of the Knesset of the State of Israel. When MK Hanamel Dorfman called out to him “you are a terror supporter,” Tibi ordered the Knesset Guard to remove him from the podium. Almog Cohen and Ofir Katz were removed after him. “Get used to the new rules,” he said. We already documented that moment.
This is who now runs Israel’s house of representatives: a man who opposes its existence as a Jewish state. He declared “we are the owners of this land”. “We were here before you and we will be here after you,” he shouted at a minister in Israel’s government. It was no slip of the tongue. In 2022 he said almost the same thing: “We are the owners of the land. We did not come here by ship or by plane.”
That claim challenges the very definition of Israel as the nation state of the Jewish people. And the man who holds it now sits on the Knesset presidium, deciding who speaks in the plenary and who is thrown out of it.
In 2011, in a speech at a “Palestinian Martyr’s Day” event in Ramallah, he also said: “In the history of nations and their struggles, the shahid is the height of glory… there is nothing more exalted than those who died for the homeland.” The Knesset Ethics Committee issued him a severe reprimand, ruling that the accepted meaning of his words was sympathy for acts of terror and violence against the State of Israel.
A day later, Emily Damari, a survivor of Hamas captivity from Kfar Aza, played the scenario out to the end. If the Knesset Speaker and the President, God forbid, were killed in the same accident, she asked, who would replace the President? “Pay attention – Ahmad Tibi!!!”
Damari also reminded everyone of what everyone knows: “Up to the moment I am writing these words, Ahmad Tibi simply chooses not to define Hamas as a terrorist organization.” And her question remains open: “Is His Excellency President Ahmad Tibi right for us?”
The law does open that path, even if not automatically. Under Basic Law: The President of the State, if the President’s office becomes vacant, the Knesset Speaker serves as acting President. And if the Speaker’s office also becomes vacant, a deputy chosen for this by the Knesset House Committee serves as acting Speaker, and in that role holds every power the law gives the Speaker, including standing in for the President.
Tibi is not an automatic successor. He is one of the deputies who could be chosen for the role. And that is exactly the point: a man who declares he owns the land, refuses to call Hamas a terrorist organization and has MKs removed from the plenary is now among the people who could receive the powers of the President of Israel.
This is the control terror supporters have gained in the Knesset. Not the government, yet. But Israel’s house of representatives, and through it, a path to the most senior formal office in the country.
Why this is dangerous
Lieberman still says he will oppose a government that relies on Ra’am and the Joint List. But the Knesset Speaker was already elected thanks to them, and their representatives already sit on the presidium. Every such step makes the next one feel more natural.
The next stage is the government confidence vote, and there every vote counts. This government can only be stopped by voting against it, not by statements and not by walking out.
An alliance of those who serve is an alliance with those who carry the burden: the soldiers, the reservists and the bereaved families. An alliance with parties that refuse to recognize Hamas as a terrorist organization is its exact opposite. You cannot talk about the first while building the second in the Knesset.
We say it clearly: Lieberman, shame on you. The soldiers expect an alliance of those who serve from you, not an alliance with the enemy.







