Deputy CEO of Breaking the Silence, Nadav Weiman, blatantly refused to shake hands with Reserve Officer Betzalel Talya, whose mother was tragically murdered in the October 7 massacre. Despite Talya’s noble attempt to display reconciliation and rise above the discord, Weiman callously rebuffed the outstretched hand. This took place while Weiman was engaging foreign journalists with messages from his anti-Zionist organization. Weiman’s action, amidst his interactions with international media, starkly contrasts Talya’s earnest endeavor to bridge divides despite immense personal grief. The rejection of an offered gesture of peace raises profound questions about the authenticity of Weiman’s organization and its proclaimed mission. This incident sheds light on the hypocrisy within Breaking the Silence, showcasing a disconnect between its publicized stance on dialogue and reconciliation while disavowing such actions in personal encounters. It reflects a lack of empathy and an unwillingness to engage constructively, casting doubt on the organization’s professed values.